Samsung Freestyle 2nd Gen vs. BenQ TH685P: Which Projector Is Right for You?

In the evolving world of home entertainment, projectors have carved out a unique niche. Unlike traditional TVs, they offer the flexibility to create massive displays without permanently dedicating wall space. Today, we're comparing two distinctly different approaches to projection technology: the lifestyle-focused Samsung Freestyle 2nd Gen and the performance-oriented BenQ TH685P gaming projector. While they both throw images onto walls, their design philosophies and ideal use cases couldn't be more different.

The Projector Landscape in 2023

Before diving into specifics, it's worth understanding where projectors fit in today's entertainment ecosystem. Traditional home theaters once required dedicated rooms with controlled lighting and expensive equipment. Modern projectors have dramatically expanded possibilities, with some designed for gaming, others for portable entertainment, and many attempting to replace traditional TVs altogether.

The projector market has evolved significantly over the past five years, with manufacturers focusing on different priorities: some chase brightness and resolution for dedicated home theaters, while others prioritize portability and smart features for flexible use. The Samsung Freestyle 2nd Gen and BenQ TH685P represent these divergent approaches perfectly.

Product Backgrounds and Evolution

The Samsung Freestyle 2nd Gen, released in early 2023, builds upon the original Freestyle launched in 2022. Samsung has made several meaningful improvements in this second iteration, most notably adding Samsung Gaming Hub support and increasing internal storage from 8GB to 16GB. The Freestyle line represents Samsung's vision of projectors as lifestyle products rather than just display devices.

The BenQ TH685P, launched in late 2022, is the successor to the popular TH685 gaming projector. BenQ refined rather than revolutionized with this update, maintaining the core gaming-focused features while improving HDMI connectivity with eARC support (Enhanced Audio Return Channel, which allows sending high-quality audio back to sound systems) and slightly enhancing color performance.

Physical Design & Portability: Form Follows Function

The Samsung Freestyle 2nd Gen immediately stands out with its unconventional cylindrical design. Weighing just 1.83 pounds and roughly the size of a small Bluetooth speaker, it's genuinely portable in a way few projectors can claim. The swiveling design allows for projection at virtually any angle – point it at walls, ceilings, or even floors with a simple rotation. This flexibility makes it ideal for impromptu movie nights in different rooms or even outdoor viewing.

"The most fascinating aspect of the Freestyle's design is how it rethinks what a projector should look like," says one industry expert. "It's essentially a spotlight form factor repurposed for projection."

In contrast, the BenQ TH685P embraces a more traditional projector design. At 6.2 pounds, it's still considered portable by conventional standards, but it's clearly designed for semi-permanent installation. Its rectangular housing contains much larger optical components that prioritize image brightness and quality over extreme portability. You can certainly move it between rooms, but you wouldn't casually toss it in a backpack like the Freestyle.

The physical difference between these units speaks to their divergent use cases: the Freestyle is designed to go anywhere and adapt to various environments, while the BenQ is built to deliver maximum performance in a more controlled setting.

Image Performance: The Heart of Projection

Brightness: The Critical Factor

Brightness is perhaps the single most important specification for practical projector use, and here the difference between our contenders is stark.

The BenQ TH685P outputs an impressive 3,500 ANSI lumens. ANSI lumens (the standardized brightness measurement for projectors) at this level means the BenQ can produce a visible, enjoyable image even with some ambient light present. You don't need a pitch-black room to use it effectively, making it practical for everyday viewing or daytime gaming sessions.

The Samsung Freestyle 2nd Gen, with approximately 550 ANSI lumens, requires significantly darker conditions. This brightness level necessitates near-darkness for optimal viewing – think evening use with lights dimmed or off. The practical implication is that the Freestyle is more of a "special occasion" device for many users, while the BenQ can potentially replace a TV for regular viewing.

"Brightness affects everything about the viewing experience," notes a projection specialist. "It determines not just when you can use the projector, but how large your image can be while maintaining visibility."

Resolution and Image Quality

Both projectors offer 1080p Full HD resolution, which remains the sweet spot for projectors in this price range. While 4K projectors exist, they typically command significantly higher prices.

The BenQ TH685P pairs its 1080p resolution with HDR10 support, enhancing contrast and color depth when playing compatible content. The high brightness level allows the HDR effect to be more pronounced, with brighter highlights and deeper blacks creating a more dynamic image. Its DLP (Digital Light Processing) technology utilizes a color wheel system that produces sharp images with excellent motion handling – particularly important for gaming and sports content.

The Samsung Freestyle 2nd Gen also supports HDR10, but its lower brightness somewhat limits the impact of this feature. Samsung compensates with sophisticated image processing that optimizes contrast and color based on content and projection surface. The Freestyle includes an adaptive color feature that adjusts the image when projecting onto colored walls – a thoughtful addition for a portable device likely to be used in various environments.

Color Reproduction and Accuracy

Color performance represents another area where these projectors take different approaches. The BenQ TH685P covers approximately 95% of the Rec.709 color space (the standard color profile for HD content), delivering accurate colors for movies and games. Its color wheel is optimized for brightness rather than the widest color gamut, making it excellent for punchy, vibrant images even with some ambient light.

The Samsung Freestyle focuses on color adaptability rather than strict accuracy. Its standout feature is the ability to analyze the color of your wall and adjust the projection accordingly, helping maintain reasonable color balance even when projecting onto non-white surfaces. This adaptive approach suits its portable nature, though color purists might prefer the more accurate reproduction of the BenQ in a controlled environment.

Gaming Performance: Response and Fluidity

For gamers, projector performance extends beyond just image quality to include responsiveness and smooth motion handling.

The BenQ TH685P excels here with remarkably low input lag – as little as 8.3ms at 1080p/120Hz in its gaming mode. Input lag (the delay between when your controller sends a signal and when that action appears on screen) at this level is imperceptible even to competitive gamers. Combined with support for refresh rates up to 120Hz (meaning the image updates 120 times per second), the BenQ delivers an exceptionally responsive gaming experience that rivals gaming monitors.

"The sub-10ms input lag on a projector was unthinkable just a few years ago," explains a gaming technology expert. "It's what makes the BenQ a true gaming projector rather than just a projector that can be used for games."

The Samsung Freestyle 2nd Gen offers a decent but less impressive gaming experience with approximately 43ms of input lag at 60Hz. This performance is adequate for casual gaming and most single-player experiences but falls short for competitive multiplayer games where split-second reactions matter. The addition of Samsung's Gaming Hub in this second-generation model does improve the gaming experience by providing easy access to cloud gaming services like Xbox Game Pass and NVIDIA GeForce NOW.

Smart Features & Connectivity: Modern Convenience

Operating Systems and Streaming

The Samsung Freestyle 2nd Gen functions essentially as a smart TV in projector form, running Samsung's Tizen operating system. This provides access to virtually all major streaming services (Netflix, Disney+, Hulu, etc.) without requiring external devices. The interface will be immediately familiar to anyone who's used a recent Samsung TV, with the same tile-based organization and voice control options. The Freestyle also supports both Bixby and Amazon Alexa voice assistants for hands-free control.

The Freestyle's smart features extend beyond entertainment to include ambient modes that transform it into a mood light or digital art display when not being used for video content. Samsung has expanded these features in the second generation, making the device more versatile as a general lifestyle product.

The BenQ TH685P takes a fundamentally different approach with no smart operating system at all. It functions purely as a display device, requiring external sources like streaming sticks, game consoles, or computers to provide content. This simplicity has advantages – the interface never feels sluggish, and you're never limited by the projector's processing power – but it does necessitate additional devices and potentially more complex setup.

Connectivity Options

Connectivity further highlights the different philosophies of these projectors. The Samsung Freestyle offers relatively minimalist connections with a single HDMI port, USB-C for power or content, and wireless options including Bluetooth, Wi-Fi, and AirPlay. This streamlined approach suits its portable nature while still providing flexibility.

The BenQ TH685P provides more robust physical connections with two HDMI ports (one supporting eARC for advanced audio setups), USB power output (convenient for powering streaming sticks), 3.5mm audio output, and even RS-232 for integration with advanced home automation systems. This connection suite is designed for more permanent home theater setups where multiple devices might be connected simultaneously.

Audio Performance: Sound Matters

Projectors typically struggle with audio due to size constraints, but both models attempt to provide usable built-in sound.

The Samsung Freestyle 2nd Gen features a 360-degree 5W speaker system that disperses sound in all directions. This omnidirectional approach works well for its portable use case, providing adequate volume and reasonable clarity for casual viewing. The speaker quality is comparable to a decent Bluetooth speaker – not home theater quality, but perfectly functional for most environments where the Freestyle might be used.

The BenQ TH685P includes a more powerful 10W speaker that achieves higher volume levels but with less refined sound quality. It's sufficient for gaming in smaller rooms but lacks bass response and clarity for truly immersive movie experiences. Most users will want to connect external speakers or a soundbar for regular use, especially given the eARC support that allows for high-quality audio passthrough to compatible sound systems.

Setup & Installation: Flexibility vs. Optimization

Throw Ratio and Screen Size

Throw ratio (the relationship between the projection distance and the resulting image size) significantly impacts where you can position a projector in your space.

The Samsung Freestyle 2nd Gen uses a fixed throw ratio that requires approximately 9 feet of distance to create a 100-inch image. This means you need adequate space between the projector and your wall, which might be challenging in smaller rooms. However, its auto-keystone correction (which automatically adjusts the image to appear rectangular even when projecting at an angle) and auto-focus features significantly simplify setup, allowing for quick deployment in various environments.

The BenQ TH685P offers more flexibility with its 1.13-1.47:1 throw ratio and 1.3x zoom lens. This allows you to achieve a 100-inch image from distances between 8 and 10.5 feet, providing more placement options. The tradeoff is more manual setup – you'll need to adjust focus, zoom, and keystone correction manually, though once set, these adjustments typically remain stable for permanent installations.

Installation Considerations

For home theater enthusiasts, the installation differences between these projectors are substantial. The BenQ includes adjustable feet and ceiling mount compatibility, making it suitable for both tabletop use and permanent installation. Its larger size accommodates better cooling systems, allowing for longer operating sessions without overheating concerns.

The Freestyle's unique mounting system allows it to rotate for projection in virtually any direction, including onto ceilings while sitting on a table. Samsung also offers optional accessories including a battery base for truly wireless operation and a light socket adapter that allows the Freestyle to be powered from a standard light fixture – a clever solution for spaces without convenient power outlets.

Value Proposition: Performance vs. Versatility

At approximately $800, the Samsung Freestyle 2nd Gen represents a premium price point for its brightness class. You're paying for the compact form factor, smart features, and flexibility rather than raw performance metrics. For users who value these attributes – particularly those who will use it in multiple locations or for creative applications beyond traditional movie watching – the value proposition makes sense.

The BenQ TH685P, typically priced around $800-900, delivers substantially more brightness and gaming performance for a similar investment. From a pure specs-per-dollar perspective, it offers superior value, especially for dedicated home theater or gaming room applications. What you sacrifice is portability and built-in smart features.

"The value equation really depends on how you'll use these devices," explains a home theater consultant. "For a dedicated media room, the BenQ gives you more performance for your money. For someone who wants projection in different rooms or outdoor movie nights, the Freestyle's convenience justifies its cost."

Real-World Use Cases: Finding Your Perfect Match

When the Samsung Freestyle 2nd Gen Shines

The Samsung Freestyle 2nd Gen excels in scenarios that leverage its portability and smart features:

• Apartment dwellers who want occasional big-screen experiences without dedicating wall space to a TV
• Frequent travelers looking for entertainment options in hotel rooms
• Families wanting backyard movie nights without complex setup
• Creative users who might project onto unusual surfaces or use the ambient features
• Those who value a self-contained entertainment system requiring no additional devices

The Freestyle's greatest strength is its versatility – it can transform almost any space into an entertainment area temporarily, then disappear when not needed.

When the BenQ TH685P Takes the Lead

The BenQ TH685P is the clear choice for:

• Dedicated gamers seeking responsive, large-screen experiences
• Home theater enthusiasts with partially light-controlled rooms
• Sports fans who gather friends to watch games on a large screen
• Users who already own streaming devices and want maximum image quality
• Those willing to set up once for ongoing use rather than frequent relocation

The BenQ's brightness advantage and gaming performance make it the superior choice for any scenario where image quality and responsiveness take priority over portability.

How to Decide: Making the Right Choice

After comparing these projectors across multiple dimensions, your decision ultimately comes down to prioritizing your specific needs:

1. If portability is paramount, the Samsung Freestyle 2nd Gen is the obvious choice. Nothing in its price class offers comparable flexibility and ease of setup for multi-location use.
2. If image quality matters most, particularly in rooms with some ambient light, the BenQ TH685P delivers substantially better performance with its superior brightness and contrast.
3. For serious gaming, the BenQ's low input lag and higher refresh rate create a notably better experience that competitive gamers will appreciate.
4. If you value smart features and want to avoid additional streaming devices, the Freestyle's built-in Tizen OS provides a more integrated, simplified experience.
5. For dedicated home theater use, the BenQ generally offers better performance, though in completely dark rooms the gap narrows somewhat.

Both the Samsung Freestyle 2nd Gen and the BenQ TH685P represent excellent executions of their respective design philosophies. The Freestyle reimagines what a projector can be, prioritizing versatility and convenience in a surprisingly capable package. The BenQ takes a more traditional approach, delivering impressive performance metrics that will satisfy home theater enthusiasts and gamers alike.

Your perfect projector depends not on which is "better" in absolute terms, but which aligns with how you'll actually use it in your space and lifestyle. Consider your viewing environment, content preferences, and whether you value flexibility over maximum performance to make the choice that will bring you the most enjoyment from your investment.

Samsung Freestyle 2nd Gen Smart Projector Deals and Prices

BenQ TH685P 1080p HDR Gaming Projector Deals and Prices