Choosing Between Modern Ultra Short Throw Projectors: A Complete Guide

When it comes to creating a big-screen experience at home, ultra short throw (UST) laser projectors have revolutionized what's possible. Two compelling options released in 2023 are the Hisense PL1 ($2,499) and the Epson EpiqVision Ultra LS650 ($1,999). Let's dive into how these projectors compare and which might be right for your setup.

Understanding Ultra Short Throw Projectors

Unlike traditional projectors that need to sit far from the screen, UST projectors use specialized optics to create large images from just inches away. This clever design lets you place them in a TV stand while projecting images up to 120 inches - that's a massive 10-foot diagonal picture! Both of these projectors use laser light sources, which offer consistent brightness and typically last 20,000+ hours without needing replacement.

Display Technology: Different Paths to 4K

The Hisense PL1 uses a single DLP chip with true 4K resolution (3840x2160 pixels). DLP (Digital Light Processing) technology uses millions of tiny mirrors that flip thousands of times per second to create the image. It's known for sharp detail and excellent motion handling, though some viewers may notice an occasional rainbow effect - brief color flashes during high-contrast scenes.

The Epson LS650 takes a different approach with 3LCD technology, using three separate LCD panels (one each for red, green, and blue). While it's not native 4K, it uses pixel-shifting to create a 4K-like image. The benefit? No rainbow effect and potentially better color uniformity. In practice, both produce detailed images that look great at normal viewing distances.

Brightness and Room Lighting: A Critical Difference

Here's where things get interesting. The Epson boasts 3,600 ANSI lumens compared to the Hisense's 2,200 ANSI lumens. What does this mean in real terms? The Epson can handle significantly more ambient light without washing out the image. If you're planning to use the projector in a living room with windows or during daytime viewing, the Epson has a clear advantage.

However, in a dedicated home theater or dark room, the Hisense's lower brightness isn't a disadvantage. In fact, it might provide better contrast and black levels in controlled lighting conditions. The Hisense also includes more sophisticated HDR processing, supporting Dolby Vision alongside HDR10 and HLG, while the Epson only handles HDR10 and HLG.

Color Performance and Image Quality

The Hisense PL1's coverage of 85% of the DCI-P3 color space is impressive, offering rich, cinema-quality colors. Combined with its Filmmaker Mode, which disables unnecessary processing to show content as directors intended, it's a serious choice for movie enthusiasts.

The Epson focuses on achieving 100% of the more limited Rec.709 color space. While this means less expansive color capabilities, it ensures accurate reproduction of most streaming content and broadcast TV. Both projectors offer various picture modes and adjustments, though the Hisense provides more extensive calibration options.

Smart Features and Usability

Both projectors include smart TV platforms - Google TV on the Hisense and Android TV on the Epson. In practice, Google TV offers a more refined experience with better content recommendations and a smoother interface. However, both give you access to major streaming services without needing an external device.

The Hisense's auto-geometry correction feature is particularly clever, using your smartphone to automatically align the image. The Epson's setup process is also straightforward but requires more manual adjustment.

Audio Solutions

Built-in audio has become increasingly important for UST projectors, and both units deliver here. The Hisense includes a 30W Dolby Atmos system that provides surprisingly immersive sound. The Epson counters with a Yamaha-designed 2.1 channel system (2x25W) that offers clear dialogue and decent bass response.

For serious home theater use, you'll want to connect external speakers or a soundbar, but both projectors' built-in audio works well for casual viewing.

Gaming Considerations

Both projectors support gaming at 4K/60Hz, though neither offers 120Hz modes found on some TVs. The Hisense includes an automatic game mode with lower input lag, while the Epson requires manual activation of its fast response setting. Both perform adequately for casual gaming, but competitive gamers might prefer a gaming-focused TV.

Value and Long-term Ownership

At $500 less, the Epson LS650 presents strong value, especially considering its higher brightness. However, the Hisense PL1 justifies its premium with better HDR support, superior color coverage, and more refined smart features.

Both use laser light sources rated for 20,000+ hours (Hisense claims 25,000), meaning they should last over a decade with typical use. The lack of replacement bulbs helps offset the initial investment compared to traditional projectors.

How to Decide

Consider these key factors when choosing between these projectors:

1. Room Environment
   • Bright room with windows: Choose the Epson
2. Dedicated theater or dark room: Choose the Hisense
3. Primary Use Case
   • Movies and streaming: Hisense offers better color and HDR
4. Sports and TV: Epson's brightness handles ambient light better
5. Budget Considerations
   • Value priority: Epson provides excellent performance for less
6. Best possible image: Hisense justifies its premium for enthusiasts
7. Technical Preferences
   • Sensitive to rainbow effect: Choose the Epson
8. Want true 4K: Choose the Hisense

Final Thoughts

Both projectors represent impressive technological achievements, offering different strengths for different situations. The Epson LS650 excels in bright rooms and provides excellent value, while the Hisense PL1 edges ahead in image quality and features for dedicated home theater use.

For most users, room lighting should be the primary deciding factor. The Epson's extra brightness makes it more versatile in typical living rooms, while the Hisense's superior HDR and color performance shine in controlled lighting conditions. Either way, you're getting a capable large-screen solution that can transform your home entertainment experience.

Hisense PL1 Laser Cinema Projector Deals and Prices

Epson EpiqVision Ultra LS650 4K Ultra Short Throw Laser Projector Deals and Prices