Ultra Short Throw Laser Projector Guide: Comparing Two Leading Options

If you're looking to create a cinema-like experience at home without dedicating space to a traditional long-throw projector, ultra short throw (UST) laser projectors offer an compelling solution. Let's dive deep into comparing two popular options: the Hisense PL1 ($2,497) and the XGIMI Aura 2 ($2,699).

Understanding UST Projectors

UST projectors use specialized optics to project large images from just inches away from your wall or screen. Unlike traditional projectors that need 10+ feet of space, these units sit close to your wall like a TV stand, making them perfect for modern living spaces.

The Technology Evolution

The Hisense PL1, released in 2023, uses a single blue laser with phosphor wheel technology (called X-Fusion) to create images. The newer XGIMI Aura 2, launched in late 2024, introduces Dual Light 2.0 technology that combines LED and laser light sources - an innovation aimed at reducing the "laser speckle" effect that can sometimes cause visual fatigue.

Image Quality Deep-Dive

Resolution and Processing

Both projectors offer 4K (3840x2160) resolution using DLP technology. However, they handle image processing differently:

• The PL1 uses advanced motion compensation (MEMC) that helps smooth out fast action but can sometimes create a "soap opera effect" that some viewers dislike
• The Aura 2's newer processor offers improved HDR tone mapping and reportedly better handles dark scene details

Color Performance

This is where we see significant differences:

• PL1: Covers 85% of DCI-P3 color space
• Aura 2: Reaches 99% of DCI-P3 coverage

For context, DCI-P3 is the color standard used in digital cinema. The Aura 2's wider coverage means more vibrant and accurate colors, especially noticeable in nature documentaries and animated content.

Brightness and Ambient Light Handling

Both projectors offer enough brightness for moderate ambient light:

• PL1: 2200 ANSI lumens
• Aura 2: 2300 ISO lumens

While these numbers seem close, they're measured using different standards. In real-world use, both perform best in controlled lighting, but can handle some ambient light without washing out completely.

Installation and Setup

The physical placement requirements differ slightly:

• PL1: 0.25:1 throw ratio, projects 100" from about 11.7" away
• Aura 2: 0.177:1 throw ratio, achieves 100" from 7" away

The Aura 2's shorter throw distance might seem better, but it also means less room for error in placement. Both projectors offer automatic geometric correction, but the Aura 2's ISA 5.0 system provides more sophisticated calibration tools.

Smart Features and Connectivity

The Hisense PL1 runs on Google TV in the US (VIDAA elsewhere), while the XGIMI Aura 2 uses Android TV. Both platforms offer access to major streaming services, though neither handles Netflix natively without workarounds - a common issue with projectors.

Key connectivity differences:

• PL1: 2x HDMI 2.1 ports
• Aura 2: 3x HDMI 2.0 ports with eARC

Audio Performance

Audio capabilities show significant differences:

• PL1: Two 15W speakers with Dolby Atmos support
• Aura 2: Four 15W Harman Kardon speakers (60W total)

The Aura 2's superior speaker system delivers noticeably better audio, though for a true home theater experience, you'll want external speakers with either unit.

Gaming Considerations

Both projectors support gaming, but with limitations:

• PL1: Includes dedicated game mode with ALLM
• Aura 2: Lower input lag in game mode, but lacks ALLM

Neither projector supports 4K/120Hz gaming, staying at 4K/60Hz maximum.

Value and Long-term Ownership

Both projectors use laser light sources rated for 20,000+ hours of use. At 4 hours daily, that's over 13 years of viewing. The $200 price difference between them might seem significant, but spread across years of use, it's minimal.

The Aura 2's newer technology and superior color reproduction might justify its higher price for videophiles, while the PL1's slightly lower price and simpler setup could appeal to those prioritizing value.

How to Decide

Choose the Hisense PL1 if:

• You want to save $200
• You prefer Google TV's interface
• You plan to use external speakers
• Simpler setup is important

Choose the XGIMI Aura 2 if:

• Color accuracy is crucial
• You want better built-in audio
• You need a shorter throw distance
• You want the latest technology

Final Thoughts

Both the Hisense PL1 and XGIMI Aura 2 represent excellent alternatives to traditional TVs, especially for those wanting screens larger than 85 inches. The PL1 offers solid performance and value, while the Aura 2 brings newer technology and superior color accuracy at a slight premium. Your choice might ultimately come down to your room setup, budget, and whether you prioritize absolute performance over value.

Hisense PL1 Laser Cinema Projector Deals and Prices

XGIMI Aura 2 Ultra Short Throw Laser Projector Deals and Prices