Choosing Between Premium Portable Speakers: Comparing the Morel BIGGIE and Marshall Emberton III

When shopping for a high-end portable speaker in 2024, you'll find quite a range in both price and capability. Today we're comparing two impressive but very different approaches: the audiophile-focused $299 Morel BIGGIE and the adventure-ready $169 Marshall Emberton III.

Understanding Modern Portable Speakers

Portable speakers have evolved significantly in recent years. We now expect great sound quality, long battery life, and robust build quality - but manufacturers take different approaches to these goals. The key is finding the right balance for your needs.

The BIGGIE and Emberton III represent two distinct philosophies. Morel, known for high-end car and home audio, brings their audiophile expertise to a semi-portable format. Marshall, with decades of music amplification experience, focuses on creating a go-anywhere speaker that still delivers their signature sound.

Sound Quality Deep Dive

Driver Configuration and Sound Staging

The BIGGIE uses a traditional two-way design with a 1-inch soft dome tweeter and 4-inch woofer - similar to what you'd find in a bookshelf speaker. This allows for precise sound reproduction, with the tweeter handling high frequencies (like cymbals and vocals) while the woofer manages mids and bass. The result is exceptional clarity and separation between instruments.

The Emberton III takes a different approach with dual 2-inch full-range drivers and passive radiators. While this doesn't provide the same level of precision, Marshall's "True Stereophonic" technology creates an impressive 360-degree soundstage that works well in outdoor settings where speaker positioning isn't always ideal.

Power and Volume Handling

With 60 watts of Class D amplification (45W to woofer, 15W to tweeter), the BIGGIE can reach impressive volumes without distortion. The dedicated amplifier channels ensure each driver receives exactly the power it needs. This becomes especially noticeable when playing complex music at higher volumes - the sound stays clean and controlled.

The Emberton III prioritizes efficiency over raw power. While Marshall doesn't publish specific wattage numbers, testing shows it performs best at moderate volumes. Its "Dynamic Loudness" feature adjusts frequency response as volume changes, ensuring balanced sound even at lower levels.

Bass Response

Here's where the size difference really shows. The BIGGIE's larger cabinet and dedicated woofer deliver impressive bass down to 40Hz - that's approaching subwoofer territory. You'll feel the impact of kick drums and bass guitars in a way that's surprising for a portable speaker.

The Emberton III's bass response starts at 65Hz, which is still respectable for its size. The dual passive radiators help create a fuller sound, but physics limitations mean it can't match the BIGGIE's low-end authority.

Portability and Durability

The BIGGIE weighs in at 5.7 pounds - definitely portable, but you'll notice it in your bag. It's built more for moving between rooms or taking to a friend's house than for hiking or beach trips. The build quality is excellent, with a solid MDF cabinet that helps minimize unwanted vibrations.

The Emberton III truly shines in portability at just 1.5 pounds. Its IP67 rating means it's fully dustproof and can handle being submerged in water for 30 minutes. The rubberized housing and metal grille are designed to survive drops and rough handling.

Battery Life and Charging

Both speakers offer impressive battery performance, but with different priorities:

BIGGIE:

• 20 hours playback at moderate volumes
• 2-hour full charge time
• 20-minute quick charge for 4 hours of play

Emberton III:

• 32 hours playback
• Quick charge providing 6 hours from 20 minutes
• More efficient power usage overall

Smart Features and Connectivity

The BIGGIE supports True Wireless Stereo for pairing two units in stereo, and both speakers are Auracast-ready (though this feature awaits activation through future updates). The BIGGIE uses Bluetooth 5.3 with an impressive 165-foot range.

The Emberton III adds hands-free calling capability and integration with Marshall's smartphone app for EQ adjustments. Its Bluetooth 5.3 implementation includes LE Audio support, promising better sound quality and lower latency once fully activated.

Value Proposition

At $299, the BIGGIE represents a significant investment, but delivers audiophile-grade sound that competes with similarly priced home speakers. The build quality and sound performance justify the price for those prioritizing audio quality.

The $169 Emberton III offers exceptional value, especially considering its durability and feature set. While it can't match the BIGGIE's sound quality, it's more versatile and practical for many users.

How to Decide

Choose the BIGGIE if:

• Sound quality is your top priority
• You'll primarily use it indoors
• You appreciate accurate musical reproduction
• You want the option to create a true stereo system with two units

Choose the Emberton III if:

• You need genuine portability
• You'll use it outdoors frequently
• Budget is a major consideration
• You want hands-free calling capability
• Long battery life is essential

Looking Forward

Both speakers show where portable audio is heading, with Auracast support and high-quality Bluetooth codecs becoming standard features. The BIGGIE demonstrates that portable speakers can deliver true high-fidelity sound, while the Emberton III shows how durability and convenience features can coexist with good audio quality.

For home theater use, the BIGGIE could serve as a capable surround speaker or music system for smaller rooms, though its price point might make dedicated home speakers a better choice. The Emberton III, while excellent for its intended use, isn't really suited for home theater applications.

The choice between these speakers ultimately comes down to your primary use case. The BIGGIE delivers exceptional sound quality for those who prioritize audio performance, while the Emberton III offers remarkable versatility and value for those needing a truly portable solution.

Morel BIGGIE Portable Bluetooth Speaker Deals and Prices

Marshall Emberton III Portable Bluetooth Speaker Deals and Prices