Marshall Portable Speaker Showdown: Willen vs Emberton II

When Marshall launched two new portable speakers in 2022, they aimed to cover different needs in the portable audio market. The compact Marshall Willen at $59.99 and the more powerful Marshall Emberton II at $119.95 both bring Marshall's iconic style to portable audio, but they serve distinctly different use cases. Let's dive into what makes each speaker special and who they're best suited for.

Understanding Portable Bluetooth Speakers in 2023

Today's portable speakers need to balance multiple competing priorities - sound quality, battery life, durability, and portability. While early Bluetooth speakers often compromised heavily on audio quality, modern speakers utilize advanced driver technology and digital signal processing to deliver impressive sound from small packages.

Both speakers showcase this evolution, featuring passive radiators (which are additional speaker membranes that move in response to air pressure from the main drivers) to enhance bass response without requiring larger enclosures or more power. This technology helps these compact speakers produce fuller sound than their size might suggest.

Sound Quality Deep Dive

Driver Configuration and Impact

The Emberton II employs dual 2-inch drivers powered by 10 watts each, plus two passive radiators. This configuration enables true stereo separation and Marshall's "True Stereophonic" technology, which creates a 360-degree soundfield. In practical terms, this means you get consistent sound quality regardless of where you place the speaker in a room.

The Willen takes a different approach with a single 2-inch driver backed by dual passive radiators. While this mono configuration can't create true stereo separation, it allows for an incredibly compact design while still maintaining respectable sound quality. The speaker projects sound primarily in one direction, making it ideal for personal listening or desktop use.

Real-world Performance

In testing, the Emberton II shows its advantages in several key areas:

• Deeper bass response (reaching down to 60Hz vs Willen's 100Hz cutoff)
• Higher maximum volume (87dB vs 82dB)
• Wider soundstage due to stereo drivers
• More balanced sound at higher volumes

The Willen, while more limited in absolute performance, impresses for its size:

• Clear midrange reproduction
• Surprisingly full sound for its compact dimensions
• Good vocal clarity
• Efficient use of its single driver

Portability and Design

Physical Characteristics

The size difference between these speakers is significant. The Willen is genuinely pocket-sized at 101.6 x 100.5 x 40.4mm and weighing just 310g. Its rubber strap adds versatility, allowing you to mount it on bike handlebars, backpack straps, or hang it from hooks.

The Emberton II, while still portable at 68 x 160 x 76mm and 700g, requires more bag space. However, its larger size enables the superior acoustic performance mentioned above.

Durability

Both speakers feature IP67 water and dust resistance, meaning they can handle:

• Submersion in 1 meter of water for 30 minutes
• Complete protection against dust
• Rain, splashes, and poolside use
• Beach environments

This level of protection makes both speakers highly versatile for outdoor use, something that wasn't common in portable speakers just a few years ago.

Battery Technology and Charging

Battery life has seen significant improvements since these speakers' release. The Emberton II leads with 30 hours of playback, while the Willen offers 15 hours. Both feature quick-charging capabilities:

Emberton II:

• 20 minutes charge = 4 hours playback
• 3 hours for full charge
• Auto-shutdown after 20 minutes idle

Willen:

• 20 minutes charge = 3 hours playback
• 3 hours for full charge
• Same auto-shutdown feature

These quick-charge capabilities represent a meaningful advance over previous generations of portable speakers, where partial charges often delivered proportionally less playback time.

Smart Features and Connectivity

Both speakers employ Bluetooth 5.1, offering:

• Dual device pairing
• Stack Mode for connecting multiple speakers
• Marshall Bluetooth app compatibility
• Over-the-air firmware updates

The Willen adds hands-free calling capability with its built-in microphone, while the Emberton II focuses purely on audio playback. The Marshall app provides EQ presets for both speakers, though neither offers fully customizable EQ settings.

Value Proposition

At their current prices, both speakers present interesting value propositions:

The Willen at $59.99 competes strongly in the ultra-portable category, offering:

• Premium build quality
• Excellent water resistance
• Versatile mounting options
• Solid sound for its size

The Emberton II at $119.95 justifies its higher price through:

• Superior sound quality
• Longer battery life
• True stereo performance
• Higher maximum volume

How to Make Your Choice

Consider your primary use case:

Choose the Willen if:

• You prioritize maximum portability
• Need speakerphone functionality
• Want to mount the speaker in different ways
• Primarily listen at moderate volumes
• Have a tighter budget

Choose the Emberton II if:

• Sound quality is your top priority
• You often listen in groups
• Need maximum battery life
• Want better performance at higher volumes
• Plan to use it as a primary portable speaker

Looking Forward

Both speakers represent Marshall's current technology in portable audio, with features like Stack Mode and app integration showing the direction of future development. While newer competitors have emerged since their 2022 release, both remain competitive in their respective categories, thanks to their robust build quality and well-implemented features.

The portable speaker market continues to evolve, with trends toward better battery life and improved sound quality in smaller packages. However, both the Willen and Emberton II remain relevant choices, particularly at their current price points, which have dropped significantly since launch.

Remember, the best choice depends heavily on your specific needs and use cases. Both speakers excel in their intended roles - the Willen as an ultra-portable personal audio device and the Emberton II as a more powerful, room-filling portable speaker.

Marshall Willen Portable Bluetooth Speaker Deals and Prices

Marshall Emberton II Portable Bluetooth Speaker Deals and Prices